llm-providers-wiki

Claude API — Refusals and Fallback

Anthropic API documentation for how Claude returns safety-classifier refusals and how to retry a refused request on a fallback model. Routed here (the provider-API-access lens) from the hub on 2026-06-11; the SDK-middleware angle is a cross-spoke adjacency with agentic-tooling-wiki (see below).

What a refusal is

Claude’s safety classifiers can decline a request. A decline is not an HTTP error — it comes back as a normal HTTP 200 with stop_reason: "refusal" and (usually) a stop_details object:

• category — the policy area that fired: "cyber", "bio", "frontier_llm" (competing-model development, restricted under Anthropic’s commercial terms), or "reasoning_extraction" (asking the model to reproduce its internal reasoning). Benign work in these areas can still trip the classifier.
• explanation — human-readable, not stable (display, don’t parse).
• Both fields (and stop_details itself) can be null; stop_details is null for every non-refusal stop reason. Branch on stop_reason == "refusal", never on stop_details/content.

A refusal can arrive before any output or mid-stream; treat partial output as incomplete.

The fallback pattern

The fix for a refusal is to re-send the same request to a different model — a request Claude declines can usually be served by another. The classic chain in the docs is claude-fable-5 → claude-opus-4-8. Three ways to wire it:

Only a safety decline triggers fallback — rate-limit/overload/server errors are returned as-is. The response marks each handoff with a fallback content block (from/to model), and the top-level model field names whoever actually answered.

Billing & cost angle (why this lives in the providers wiki)

This is as much a cost/pricing feature as a reliability one:

• A refusal before any output costs nothing and consumes no rate limit; a mid-stream refusal bills the input + already-streamed output at normal rates.
• Each attempt bills separately at its own model’s rate — tokens from different models are never summed. usage.iterations[] is the per-attempt billing record (declined model = message entry; serving model = fallback_message entry).
• A manual retry re-writes the fallback model’s prompt cache from scratch; the fallback-credit-2026-06-01 beta refunds that double-cost (server-side fallback & the SDK middleware apply it automatically).
• Sticky routing: after a fallback, ~1h org-scoped best-effort routing sends later requests for that conversation straight to the model that served it — avoiding paying for an attempt that would predictably be re-declined.

Operational notes

• Batches: refusals come back as succeeded + stop_reason: "refusal" (and stop_details may be null); server-side fallbacks is not supported for batches — resubmit refused items on a fallback model.
• Refusals are an HTTP 200, so error-rate/5xx monitoring never sees them — instrument refusals and fallback-served responses as their own signal.
• Budget retries per request (a turn can produce several refusals, e.g. an agent + its sub-agents); the fallbacks param does not propagate into model calls made inside tool execution, so sub-agent calls need their own.

Cross-spoke adjacency

• agentic-tooling-wiki — the SDK middleware and the sub-agent / agent-harness framing are agent-tooling concerns; the same refusal-fallback mechanism shows up there as a robustness pattern for harnesses. Routed here because the dominant substance is the Anthropic API surface + model routing + how it’s billed.
• research-wiki — owns anthropic and claude-opus-4-8 as model-substrate bridge nodes.